Carlisle City Messageboard

Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Webb- was he good or bad?


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2957
Date:
Webb- was he good or bad?
Permalink   


http://uk.eurosport.yahoo.com/12072010/58/world-cup-2010-howard-webb-hero-villain.html

I'm fairly sure that most South American refs, and some European, would have been dishing red cards all over the place. I actually thought he booked too many early on, and was making a rod for his own back. I know Holland were getting stuck in, but some of the Tv pundits were going over the top about their tactics. I'm not quite sure what De Jong was doing- his challenge was unusual to say the least- but apart from that, there were no red-card challenges I saw.

Spain have the knack of falling over too easily, which doesn't help. Iniesta is a great player, but he was winning free-kicks with theatrical falls, and Villa is just as bad.

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2957
Date:
Permalink   

De Jong in action

clog.jpg

__________________
Scott Pilley

Date:
Permalink   

Brian wrote:

I'm fairly sure that most South American refs, and some European, would have been dishing red cards all over the place. I actually thought he booked too many early on, and was making a rod for his own back. I know Holland were getting stuck in, but some of the Tv pundits were going over the top about their tactics. I'm not quite sure what De Jong was doing- his challenge was unusual to say the least- but apart from that, there were no red-card challenges I saw.

Spain have the knack of falling over too easily, which doesn't help. Iniesta is a great player, but he was winning free-kicks with theatrical falls, and Villa is just as bad.


Have to disagree, Brian. You're right about De Jong. If you did that to someone on the street, you'd be arrested! Clear red and I can only think that HW was badly positioned.
He did try to have a 'word' with one or two players but this clearly wasn't working and so had no choice but to start cautioning. Van Bommel should have walked for persistant fouling after picking up his yellow (which might have been red on another day). Robben should have gone for at least two cases of clear dissent. In theory, Holland could have been down to nine by half-time.
The Spanish weren't innocent either, mind. I thought HW and his team dealt with what was massive pressure and the Dutch didn't help having decided to kick their way through the game

 



__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 147
Date:
Permalink   

Dutch did not have the confidence to play football and so used Rangers tactics to stop better players playing the game.

It happens in Glasgow at least 3 times a year. Should make all World Cup Refs take charge of an old firm game as practice !!!!!!!!

__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.



Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard